Starting back in the waning months of 1999, GutterAlley came into fruition. Barring the scores from those first couple of seasons, we have meticulously kept track of every single game rolled in the league ever since. We've focused a lot of our Top 25s on individuals and teams but what about the league as a collective? Here's a run down of which seasons were the best in our league's history, minus those first few.Check out our Top 25 Best Seasons:
| The Best Seasons in League History -- Ranking All Recorded Seasons | ||
| Rank | Season | League Average |
| 1. | Spring 2021 | 169.5310 |
| 2. | Spring 2015 | 168.8457 |
| 3. | Fall 2014 | 167.0076 |
| 4. | Fall 2020 | 165.1606 |
| 5. | Fall 2016 | 164.3439 |
| 6. | Spring 2018 | 160.9295 |
| 7. | Spring 2016 | 160.6998 |
| 8. | Spring 2013 | 160.3880 |
| 9. | Fall 2015 | 159.9592 |
| 10. | Fall 2012 | 159.6012 |
| 11. | Spring 2014 | 158.9243 |
| 12. | Spring 2020 | 157.9543 |
| 13. | Fall 2019 | 156.2457 |
| 14. | Fall 2013 | 155.5152 |
| 15. | Fall 2022 | 153.4884 |
| 16. | Spring 2004 | 153.4851 |
| 17. | Fall 2004 | 152.2851 |
| 18. | Spring 2017 | 152.1920 |
| 19. | Spring 2007 | 152.1806 |
| 20. | Fall 2011 | 151.8061 |
| 21. | Spring 2023 | 151.5707 |
| 22. | Fall 2017 | 151.3001 |
| 23. | Fall 2007 | 151.1395 |
| 24. | Spring 2006 | 150.5436 |
| 25. | Spring 2008 | 150.0633 |
| 26. | Fall 2003 | 150.0341 |
| 27. | Spring 2024 | 149.9517 |
| 28. | Spring 2003 | 149.4639 |
| 29. | Spring 2010 | 149.0574 |
| 30. | Fall 2021 | 148.8244 |
| 31. | Spring 2012 | 148.6644 |
| 32. | Fall 2018 | 148.5638 |
| 33. | Spring 2022 | 148.5120 |
| 34. | Spring 2005 | 146.9022 |
| 35. | Fall 2006 | 146.6867 |
| 36. | Midsummer 2021 | 146.3480 |
| 37. | Fall 2005 | 146.2658 |
| 38. | Spring 2019 | 145.6484 |
| 39. | Fall 2023 | 145.6381 |
| 40. | Fall 2024 | 145.5328 |
| 41. | Fall 2010 | 144.3615 |
| 42. | Fall 2009 | 144.1087 |
| 43. | Spring 2009 | 143.7664 |
| 44. | Spring 2002 | 143.7083 |
| 45. | Fall 2002 | 143.3305 |
| 46. | Fall 2008 | 142.9723 |
| 47. | Spring 2011 | 141.3107 |
| 48. | Fall 2000 | 133.6587 |
