Calculating the best bowlers in our league's history was a tough task and is bound to elicit arguments. Having experimented with a points based system combining variables such as lifetime average, number of wins, and a number of other factors it was ultimately scrapped in favor of just going with a purely empirical route – selecting each bowler's best season-ending average.* With that, here are the top 25 bowlers in our league's history:
| Top 25 Bowlers of All Time | ||||
| Rank | Bowler | Average | Total Pins | Season |
| 1. | Brian Coe | 219.687 | 10545 | Fall 2014 |
| 2. | Don Glasscock | 219.095 | 9202 | Fall 2007 |
| 3. | Kody Karnes | 214.729 | 10307 | Spring 2015 |
| 4. | Carl Goetz | 212.125 | 10182 | Spring 2015 |
| 5. | Ken M. Wilson | 210.583 | 10108 | Spring 2013 |
| 6. | Matthew Taylor | 206.000 | 7416 | Spring 2021 |
| 7. | David Codding | 204.916 | 7377 | Fall 2009 |
| 8. | Ian Goetz | 203.291 | 9758 | Spring 2015 |
| 9. | Cory Chorpenning | 203.095 | 8530 | Fall 2008 |
| 10. | Ryan Doll | 201.044 | 9047 | Fall 2014 |
| 11. | Aaron Barber | 200.187 | 9609 | Spring 2018 |
| 12. | Bill Krejci | 199.444 | 7180 | Spring 2013 |
| 13. | Aubrey Moren | 198.285 | 8328 | Spring 2014 |
| 14. | Michael Gordon | 198.000 | 6534 | Spring 2021 |
| 15. | John Boren | 196.976 | 8273 | Fall 2016 |
| 16. | Duncan Ferber | 195.714 | 8220 | Fall 2007 |
| 17. | Landon Cline | 194.555 | 8755 | Fall 2016 |
| 18. | Seth Gunderson | 193.857 | 8142 | Spring 2015 |
| 19. | Michael Mead | 193.333 | 9280 | Fall 2017 |
| 20. | Dennis Walling | 192.750 | 7710 | Spring 2018 |
| 21. | Pat Searcy | 191.071 | 8025 | Fall 2004 |
| 22. | Kendall Kukowski | 188.600 | 8487 | Fall 2008 |
| 23. | Jason Carpio | 188.242 | 6212 | Fall 2011 |
| 24. | Brian Eye | 187.625 | 9006 | Fall 2007 |
| 25. | Russell Bingham | 186.250 | 6705 | Spring 2018 |
