While the league has been, to quote Bill Riley, more or less "a sausage fest" since its inception, many members of the opposite sex have graced the lanes of GutterAlley since the very beginning. We've decided to showcase the best of the best in this list, determining the rankings by selecting each bowler’s best season-ending average.*Here are the Top 25 Female Bowlers of All Time:
| Top 25 Female Bowlers of All Time | ||||
| Rank | Bowler | Average | Total Pins | Season |
| 1. | Angela Bradford | 174 | 8375 | Spring 2015 |
| 2. | Freda Schroeder | 167 | 8056 | Spring 2010 |
| 3. | Anita Osthoff | 166 | 6973 | Fall 2013 |
| 4. | Kathy Smith | 162 | 7812 | Fall 2000 |
| 5. | Monica Hufford | 155 | 5590 | Spring 2018 |
| 6. | Jennifer Seefeldt | 150 | 5857 | Fall 2007 |
| 7. | Teresa Deterding | 144 | 5616 | Spring 2014 |
| 8. | Andrea Caudillo | 143 | 5610 | Fall 2009 |
| 9. | Janelle (Laube) Lamar | 141 | 6794 | Spring 2003 |
| 10. | Jessica Thomas | 141 | 5101 | Fall 2010 |
| 11. | Alison Radke | 140 | 5483 | Spring 2019 |
| 12. | Sarah Sauer | 138 | 4565 | Spring 2010 |
| 13. | Deena Slinkard | 136 | 4917 | Spring 2004 |
| 14. | JoAnne Barber | 135 | 6106 | Spring 2022 |
| 15. | Tanya Collins | 134 | 5651 | Fall 2000 |
| 16. | Andee Weinfurt | 134 | 5636 | Fall 2003 |
| 17. | Carrie Payne | 133 | 5207 | Fall 2000 |
| 18. | Chelsie Finger | 131 | 5502 | Fall 2015 |
| 19. | Kathy Labonte | 131 | 4722 | Fall 2000 |
| 20. | Sara Bryant | 128 | 4245 | Spring 2007 |
| 21. | Tracy Rychlewski | 126 | 6095 | Spring 2006 |
| 22. | Shannon Myers | 125 | 5632 | Spring 2003 |
| 23. | Kelly Minihan | 125 | 5276 | Spring 2009 |
| 24. | Amanda Schulte | 125 | 5258 | Spring 2005 |
| 25. | Michelle Shoemaker | 125 | 5257 | Spring 2016 |
